Different environments might influence energy expenditure (EE) from physical activity (PA) monitors. We evaluated and compared the test-retest reliability and criterion validity of the Sensewear mini (SWAmini) and Actiheart (AH) to estimate EE in two climatologically different countries, i.e. Suriname (tropical rainforest climate) and Belgium (oceanic climate). Fifty-six healthy participants (18–40 years) were recruited (Suriname: n = 30; Belgium n = 26). On three occasions they completed a standardized protocol including sitting, standing, low (LOW), moderate (MOD) and vigorous (VIG) intensity walking on a treadmill whilst wearing both PA monitors and a metabolic measurement system. The first session was a familiarization test, the second and third were used for reliability [intraclass correlation (ICC)] and validity analysis (mean absolute percentage error calculations, Bland-Altman, and scatterplots). Comparisons between countries were done by independent sample t-tests. We found i) fair to excellent SWAmini reliability [ICC between 0.41 (0.04–0.70) and 0.97 (0.92–0.99)]; ii) good to excellent AH reliability [ICC between 0.72 (0.45–0.87) and 0.96 (0.92–0.98)]; iii) underestimation of EE for all activities except for LOW by SWAmini; iv) in Belgium EE underestimation was greater by the SWAmini for sitting (Suriname: 5% ± 20% vs Belgium: 15% ± 12%) and by the AH for VIG (Suriname:18% ± 26% vs Belgium:37% ± 16%) v) overall poor agreement between AH and metabolic measurement system. The reliability of the PA monitors is between fair and excellent in both environments. There is a difference in validity between the two environments for sitting activities by the SWAmini and for VIG by the AH.

NOTE: The Bodymedia Sensewear Armband has been discontinued since the sale of Bodymedia to the consumer company ‘Jawbone’ in 2013. Jawbone subsequently went into liquidation in 2017 and all product support was discontinued. This illustrates the danger of choosing consumer focussed products for scientific research. Our professional, research grade Actiheart device has been available since 2003 and has hundreds of peer-reviewed publications.

Direct Link: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12553-019-00326-3

Journal: . Health and Technology. 2019 Aug 1;9(4):647-56

Keywords: climate, humidity, Physical Activity, temperature,

Applications: Energy Expenditure,

CamNtech Reference: AH19007

Back to Search Results

UK & International customers

CamNtech Ltd.
Manor Farm
PE28 9JD, UK

US customers

CamNtech Inc.
630 Boerne Stage Airfield,
Texas 78006,


© 2024 CamNtech Ltd and CamNtech Inc

Company information

Registered in England No. 2221302
VAT No: GB486 3019 34

Privacy Policy